Reforming Public Sector Pay Could Create Yorkshire Jobs
10:22am 4th September 2012
Reforming public sector pay could create forty-five thousand jobs in Yorkshire.
That's according to a conservative think tank.
It's claimed bringing it into line with the private sector would save more than a billion pounds a year.
Reforming public sector pay and pensions could create 45,000 new jobs in Yorkshire.
Reforming the way public sector workers are paid could play a vital part in boosting the economy and improving public services.
Policy Exchange says that rebalancing the pay and pensions of public sector workers so that they are in line with that of equivalent workers in the private sector would save £6.3billion a year in public spending. In Yorkshire and Humberside, £1.47billion a year could be saved, money which could be spent on creating 45,000 private sector jobs or the equivalent salaries of 52,000 more nurses of 39,000 more teachers.
The report, Local pay, local growth, says that the public sector 'premium' – the additional pay a typical public sector worker receives over a private sector worker – now stands at around 7% for the average worker. Combined with increased generosity in pensions the total ‘premium’ is nearly 14% for the average worker in the public sector. In some parts of the country, some public sector workers are seeing premiums over their private sector counterparts that are as high as 25%.
The report, co-written by a former Treasury civil servant, argues that this situation has arisen because of the system of national pay bargaining, which means that workers are paid the same amount regardless of where they live. It recommends abolishing this system and enabling local public sector employers to choose systems of pay that reflect local living conditions and vary pay awards by the performance of employees.
It says that, despite accounting for around £180billion of government spending (12.3% of GDP) the current system of paying public sector workers by nationally-set pay bands:
- Is unfair to public sector workers in high-cost areas whose living standards are worse because their pay cannot be increased above the national rate
- Damages vital public services because local schools and hospitals struggle to recruit and retain the right staff in high cost areas. Recent academic studies have shown that this can lead to a drop in educational attainment in schools and a rise in deaths in hospitals
- Damages the economy since it wastes valuable public money that could be used to boost growth and cut unemployment on areas being hit hardest by the recession
Moving to a system where public and private sector pay and pensions are aligned will take time so in the short term, the report also recommends a permanent freeze on annual pay scale uplifts and the abolition of automatic pay progression points. Pay increases for public sector employees across the country should then be based on a system of performance related pay - with total increases in each area tailored to reduce the existing pay differential between public and private sector employees.
Savings would be ring-fenced for extra public expenditure in the areas affected. Nowhere would see a fall in public expenditure as a result of these policies.
The report predicts that any move to abolish national pay bargaining will be met with significant opposition from the trade unions but calls on the government to push ahead with the reforms which will deliver increased growth, reduced unemployment and better public services.
Matthew Oakley, co-author of the report:
“The current system of national pay bargaining is bad for the economy and bad for public services. Moving to a system where local public sector employers can decide how to negotiate salaries with employees will enable top performing public sector workers to be paid more, increasing productivity and improving public services.
“Our proposals would mean that not a single penny would leave poorer regions. All the money would be ploughed back into reducing unemployment and boosting growth in the poorest parts of the country.”
|Get the latest local news direct to your inbox.
Sign up now for our email updates.